Hello All!
First time posting here - please be gentle.
After reading god knows how many pages of this, we have at least two schools of thoughts.
1) A large portion of the YLODs experienced by PHAT PS3s are caused by NEC/TOKIN Capacitors dying over time, just as they did in Toshiba laptops back in the day. This may or may not be exacerbated by the incredible heat cycles that the PS3 goes through. Reballing the GPU and CPU isn't necessary in the majority of cases.
2) The idea of replacing NEC/TOKIN Capacitors with Tantalum Capacitors is stupid because the properties of the Tantalum Capacitors are completely different to that of the NEC/TOKIN Capacitors.
The primary proponent of the 2nd idea is a poster called
@squeept who definitely does have a vested interest in that he sells reballed PS3s. However, that doesnt make him wrong, and it doesn't make him right.
He has said that the vast majority of NEC/TOKIN Capacitors he has found are absolutely fine. He has also said that whilst the capacitance of the NEC/TOKIN Capacitors does change with heat, they do so only temporarily and so the idea that reballing is fixing these machines because it heats up the secaps is folly. Again, this may or may not be true, but I wonder if there could be a different issue with the caps. They way they are on the board makes it unlikely that it could be a contact issue, but are these caps not in layers?
@squeept has been testing them by pulling them off the board... which would presumably push these layers together allowing them to work again.
What I am interested in right now, is whether we can come up with a guide on how to diagnose what the actual issue is.
One of the things he said early on is, to try to put a lot of weight on the GPU/CPU and see if it turns on. That seems like a sensible step 1 - the caps aren't affected. If so, it implies a problem with the RSX/CPU not the caps?
Could that be a good first step, and if so, what would be the second step (before yanking caps off the board)